sonic_the_hedgehog_and_friends_wallpaper_by_sonicthehedgehogbg-d6s9edsHypothetical Casting: Sonic the Hedgehog

Sony announced recently that they are developing a combination CGI and Live Action “Sonic the Hedgehog” adaptation to film. What could go wrong?

According to the official statement, the film hopes to “capture Sonic’s irreverent tone and spirit, reuniting him with some of the most revered and infamous characters of the franchise.”

“There are limitless stories to tell with a character like Sonic the Hedgehog, and a built-in international fan base,” said Hannah Minghelle, Columbia Pictures’ president of Production, “we’re looking to capture everything that generations of fans know and love about Sonic while also growing his audience wider than ever before.”

The franchise has been adapted into several different television series’, some better than others. Regardless, it is hard to tell if this movie will actually be good. It’s a movie based off a video game for children that blends live action and CGI. It could be good, but it doesn’t have much going for it at this time, but…

Maybe a good cast would help? Here’s a hypothetical casting for Sonic the Hedgehog, the live action/CGI film.

Click “continue reading” to see our casting picks:

Sonic-the-HedgehogSonic the Hedgehog

Sonic has always had that rad, skater-kid tone where his pitch his high, but he speaks with cockiness. For these castings an ideal choice would be some of the voice actors who have already played the characters in the games. For Sonic that’d be Ryan Drummond, Jason Griffith, Roger Craig Smith, or even Jaleel White even though his voice has probably changed a bit in the last twenty years.

Hollywood, however, will likely search for more popular voice actors to help promote the film. So keep in mind, we’d ideally want to see some of these voice actors reprise the role, but we will likely see more familiar faces.

Here are our picks for Sonic:

1. Jason Schwartzman

Going through several animated films to get ideas, the voice acting of Ash in “Fantastic Mr. Fox” came to mind. Schwartzman owned that character, even though Ash’s voice doesn’t quite resemble that of Sonics, I can see Schwartzman altering his tone a bit and pulling off this character.

2. Dave Franco

Franco hasn’t really had a breakout role yet, and his voice acting resume only extends as far as a small bit role in “The LEGO Movie.” Still, taking into account his voice itself, if he can add a bit of energy to the pattonend Franco lazy-tone, I could see him playing the Hedgehog.

3. Zac Efron

Similar to Franco, I think the voice is young and fresh enough, but Efron would need to add a lot of energy to the role and may have to alter his voice to a higher pitch.

tails-sonic-the-hedgehog-31448871-640-479Miles Tails Prower

Even though Tails is a male character, he is usually voiced by a woman. The pitch is just too high for many male actors to pull off.

Here are our picks for Tails:

1. Melissa Hutchison

I was trying to dig up who could pull off this role, it was very difficult though. So I stopped thinking movies and started thinking video games. Melissa Hutchison is primarily known for her voice-work in “The Walking Dead” Telltale game series as Clementine, a little girl. The pitch would be slightly lower to play Tails.

2. Veronica Taylor

She is probably most well known for the main protagonist Ash in the “Pokemon” franchise. Another big role was voicing April O’Neil in the 2003-2009 “Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle” series. She seems to have quite a range when it comes to voice acting, and Tails won’t have as manly a voice as Ash or as feminine a voice as April, so Taylor should be able to land somewhere in the middle.

3. American Ferrera

In the real world she is known for playing “Ugly Betty,” but in animation she’s known for playing Astrid in both “How to Train Your Dragon” and its sequel. She doesn’t have the same accolades for voice acting is the two other contenders have, but I think she could manage a good voice for Tails.

Knuckles-sonic-the-hedgehog-31326594-640-479Knuckles the Enchidna

Knuckles has a bit more of a manly voice, it’s similar to Sonic’s but his voice has always made him sound older, and somehow even cockier than Sonic.

Here are our picks for Knuckles:

1. Alan Tudyk

We all know Alan Tudyk, he seems to be everywhere, but he has also done a bunch of voice work. The role that lead me to believe he’d be perfect for Knuckles was King Candy in “Wreck-It Ralph.” I can see him bring enough cockiness and energy to this role.

2. Chris Pratt

Similar to Tudyk, I can see Pratt doing a fantastic job. He did exceptional voice work earlier this year in “The LEGO Movie” as the main protagonist.

3. T.J. Miller

Most recently Miller has become well known for playing the comic relief in Mike Judge’s “Silicon Valley” on HBO. But his strongest resume is in animation including playing Tuffnut in the “How to Train Your Dragon” movies.

imagesDr. Robotnik (Dr. Eggman)

I’m hoping they go with Robotnik, never was a fan of Eggman. Robotnik is, and has always been the main villain of the Sonic franchise. He is an evil genius enslaving animals in robotic bodies, but he is also known for being clumsy and quite humorous.

Keep in mind, this film is supposedly going to blend live action, however it’s hard to see Robotnik being portrayed as a real person, so we just did the voice, even though these actors could probably also pull of the mustache.

Here are our picks for Dr. Robotnik:

1. Bryan Cranston (Voice, or Both)

Imagine Cranston putting on a lot of weight (or just faking the weigh), and growing out a long fake mustache, he may be able to pull of the look right? Yeah, that’s a stretch, but imagine him voicing this character. His voice is deep and menacing enough to pull it off, and he’s talented enough to provide a nice cartoony touch.

2. Ray Winstone (Both)

Winstone could make the look come to life with some effort. If not, his voice may also be deep and menacing enough to play Robotnik.

3. John C. Reilly (Both)

His voice may not be menacing enough, but I think Reilly could darken his voice and add a nice comedic edge to the performances, especially if he plays the character in live action.

473231Shadow the Hedgehog

Who knows if Shadow will even be in this film debut, but if he is there are many low-toned actors that could totally pull off the abundance of cool that Shadow has.

Here are our picks for Shadow:

1. Will Arnett

When I first started thinking of people to voice Shadow, I couldn’t get Will Arnett’s performance as Batman in “The Lego Movie” out of my head. He would own this role.

2. Mark Hamill

In addition to playing the iconic role of Luke Skywalker in the original “Star Wars” trilogy, Hamill has delivered several strong voice acting performances, including the Joker in the “Batman” animated series.

amy_rose__sonic_the_hedgehog_characters__by_glownoxshadow-d6ci5vrAmy Rose

Another character that may or may not find her way into the movie is Sonic’s love interest.

Here are our picks for Amy:

1. Alison Brie

I know we’ve done “The Lego Movie” a lot, but that film did demonstrate many types of characters, one was Alison Brie’s performance as the happy Unikitty with an angry side. She nailed it, her voice would be high enough to play Amy, and I think she’d bring a lot of energy to the role.

2. Joan Cusack

Her resume for animation is lead by her performance as Jesse in “Toy Story 2” and “Toy Story 3,” the voices wouldn’t sound similar, but she could play a love interest with her usual voice, and again provide a lot of energy.

Who would you pick for these roles?